A symbol for the ⁂ fediverse

Jeena · 3M

A symbol for the ⁂ fediverse

Handles · 3M

There already is a symbol for the fediverse:

This has existed for years already, is used widely, and IMHO looks way better than this dull attempt. I see no good argument in the campaign website for using this new one instead.

_NoName_ · 3M

Gimme an ASCII character for it. We can replace the bitcoin character with it

Handles · 3M

Yes please!

Corgana · 3M

This logo is really unpopular hence why there is always so much talk of making something cleaner and more professional.

Handles · 3M

…and this latest proposal certainly isn’t either of those things.

This logo is really unpopular

Source? I’ve only ever seen a handful of strawman arguments that “I’m not offended by the vague resemblance to a pentagram/use of rainbow colours implying LGBTQ+ support, but somebody might be”, but its fairly wide adoption suggests that most people — myself included — actually like it.

Corgana · 3M

This is the first I’m hearing of any issue with it resembling a pentagram, the criticisms I’ve heard involve the design in general not looking professional, not scaling well, and lacking a unique palette.

The Cuuuuube · 3M

The weak argument they make is this doesn’t look good at small sizes. Personally I don’t think that constitutes a good enough reason to rebrand the fediverse

Handles · edit-2 3M

Exactly. A logo isn’t meant to work at 11 point size in the middle of inline text. The typographical argument is nonsense, and I think this proposal is really a reaction to the idiotic “Satanic panic” over the rainbow pentacle.

@uis@lemm.ee · edit-2 3M

It is not pentacle, it is 10-colored 5-node complete graph.

For people who didn’t study in school entire life is filled with magic.

Handles · 3M

Well played 👏😄

The Cuuuuube · 3M

Yeah which if that’s the argument we’re having… I kinda don’t want to give people that dumb any influence. The fediverse symbol is not a pentagram and if the rainbow giving gay people visibility is somehow wrong, then… Fuck me I guess because I’d rather make gay people comfortable than a bunch of folks who’ve fallen down some manner of christofascist rabbit hole

Handles · 3M

💯

Tippon · 3M

I commented on the last post about this, the three stars are difficult to make out on a small screen, they look like a blurry capital A. On top of that, it’s apparently used in astronomy to represent clusters of stars, like a constellation.

The whole point of this campaign appears to be to replace a unique symbol with one that’s already in use and is hard to read at small sizes 🤷🏻‍♂️

@spaduf@slrpnk.net · 3M

On top of that, it’s apparently used in astronomy to represent clusters of stars, like a constellation.

Isn’t that kind of perfect though